Which firms will be allowed to import or produce HCFCs in 2001 is in dispute because Italy is holding out against a European Commission proposal to alter the regulation's reference year for quota calculations. The issue was overlooked when the EU regulation was negotiated; the Commission now wants to change the reference year from 1996 to 1999, the latest for which figures are available.
It says the market has undergone enormous changes over this period, and a failure to adjust the date would prevent over 25 firms that currently import HCFCs from obtaining a quota next year. This would "severely affect" their businesses, an official said. The proposal was based on the "minimum market interference" principle and sought to avoid possible legal actions, he added. In addition, it would not affect next year's global cap on HCFC volumes allowed on the EU market. This is set to fall progressively to 2015 and next year will be 25% lower than in 2000.
Italy's reasons for opposing the new reference year are obscure and no officials have been available this week to explain its position. One EU diplomat said it was still not clear whether the stand was a question of principle "or whether it's about certain companies losing out." An industry source speculated today that the 1996 date might particularly favour Italian firms.
The dispute must be settled "within days," the Commission official said, since the regulation comes into force on the first of October and the 2001 quotas need to be agreed soon. Another EU source expressed frustration that such a minor issue could cause so much disruption: "I don't know why we're arguing about it. The change [in the quotas] will be so small they won't notice it."
European Commission, tel: +32 2 299 1111.
Please enter your details
Not a subscriber?
Take a free trial now to discover the critical insights and updates our coverage offers subscribers.