Chemical firm accused of "mass manslaughter"

Italian magistrates launch criminal investigation; WWF claims public also at risk

Italian magistrates in the southern city of Brindisi have placed 68 managers of a formerly state-owned petrochemical plant under investigation after a four-year inquiry found that 14 employees had died from cancer and another 83 became ill.

Workers at the site owned by Enichem, Montedison and two other private firms are thought to have developed cancer as a result of prolonged exposure to vinyl chloride - the basic building block of PVC plastic - and other toxic substances. The plant was shut down by police on Thursday.

The plant's 68 managers are accused of mass manslaughter and involuntary environmental disaster for failing to take precautionary measures to safeguard employees' health. The first cases of illness were reported there 20 years ago.

Fears are now surfacing that emissions from the plant may have affected surrounding residents as well as employees. At the request of the local authority, Italy's environment minister Willer Bordon has convened an urgent meeting set for 17 November over the question of environmental monitoring in the entire Brindisi area.

The environment ministry and environmental groups Legambiente and WWF have said they will take part in an eventual criminal lawsuit against the plant owners that could result in even larger damages than those awarded to employees at the Porto Marghera industrial complex near Venice. Some 320 individuals shared euros 32.7m (IL63.3bn) in this case.

Citing World Health Organisation data, Legambiente points out that tumour rates in the industrial areas of Brindisi are a record 48% higher than the regional average, the greatest excess seen in any part of Italy. Other industrial areas in the south and also in the centre-north also present tumour rates way above the regional average, notably Crotone (+46%), Taranto (+22%) and Massa Carrara (+21%). As many as 11 million Italians are at risk, Legambiente says.

The association has called for decontamination of the entire area, inspection of all its industrial plants, epidemiological screening of all individuals who have worked at the plant, and closure of all facilities found to pose environmental and health hazards. Adequate controls and environmental impact analysis were not been carried out at the plant, despite warning the signals sent out over decades, Legambiente said.

They held a protest at the factory gates on Tuesday.

Follow Up:
Italian environment ministry, tel: +39 06 572 2580; Legambiente, tel: +39 06 86 26 81.

Please sign in to access this article. To subscribe, view our subscription options, or take out a free trial.

Please enter your details

Forgotten password?

Having trouble signing in?

Contact Customer Support at
or call 020 8267 8120

Not a subscriber?

Take a free trial now to discover the critical insights and updates our coverage offers subscribers.