Energy tax plan back on EU political agenda

Commission, Austria, press for EU-wide measure; new compromise could satisfy reluctant states

The idea of an EU-wide energy tax is back on the table following a high-level meeting between member states and the European Commission on Friday.

The meeting was called by EU taxation commissioner, Mario Monti, who hoped to break the deadlock on a draft directive proposed by the Commission last March that would, for the first time, impose EU-wide minimum rates of excise duty on most energy products (ENDS Daily 13 March). Austria, which last week identified tax harmonisation as a priority for its six-month EU presidency term, will try to broker a compromise deal in ministerial working groups in the coming months.

At Friday's meeting of the so-called "Monti group," which discusses EU tax issues, junior ministers and senior civil servants discussed three possible compromise approaches on the proposal, which are designed to address fears among the poorer member states - Spain, Portugal, Greece and Ireland - that the directive would push up inflation.

Following the discussion, sources say, Austria will hold further talks based on a proposal involving the possibility of long transition periods for certain states. The presidency will also propose setting EU-wide minimum excise duties for gas, coal and electricity - currently not taxed in most EU countries - at zero. This would mean no immediate impact on energy prices, but would force EU countries to put system in place so that minimum EU energy taxes could be levied in the future, a Commission official told ENDS Daily.

Another concession that will be considered, according to a Commission source, would be to allow member states to exempt domestic users from the taxes, aiming the measures instead at industrial and commercial energy consumers. This would be especially aimed at securing support for the plan from the UK, which indicated in Friday's meeting that taxing householders' energy use would be politically unthinkable.

Progress on the issue will be slow, not only because unanimity will be needed but also because of particular circumstances in two member states. At the meeting, Germany said any serious negotiations would have to wait until after its general election in September and the UK said it could make no decisions on energy policy until November when a government task force publishes a report on the possible introduction of energy tax for business and industry (ENDS Daily 17 March).

A Brussels diplomat added that "significant differences" between the member states would mean issue would "almost certainly" drag on into the German Presidency, which begins in January.

Follow Up:
European Commission, tel: +32 2 295 1111.

Please sign in to access this article. To subscribe, view our subscription options, or take out a free trial.

Please enter your details

Forgotten password?

Having trouble signing in?

Contact Customer Support at
or call 020 8267 8120

Not a subscriber?

Take a free trial now to discover the critical insights and updates our coverage offers subscribers.