Chemical firms targeted over toxic ship paints

Norwegian NGO, law firm, recommend court action to help pay for Oslo harbour clean-up

Friends of the Earth's Norwegian branch is calling for at least two chemical firms to be taken to court after linking polychlorinated biphenyl (PCB) in Oslo harbour sludge to their ship paint products. The study was commissioned by the local municipality, which wants to launch a clean-up operation but doesn't want to shoulder the entire costs, estimated at NKr200,000 (euros 24,400).

In the spotlight are Bayer and Solutia (formerly Monsanto), and to a lesser extent Japanese firm Kanegafuchi Chemicals Industry Co. Having demonstrated through "chemical fingerprints" what it says is a strong link between these companies' products and PCB in Oslo harbour sludge, the Norwegian Society for the Conservation of Nature (NNV) is demanding that they be forced to pay at least half the costs of any clean-up operation.

Oslo has one of the most polluted harbours in Norway, according to NNV, with PCB levels of up to 4,000 parts per million. Successfully launching court action against any of the targeted chemical firms "could set an international precedent" for environmental liability, according to the group's Tom Erik Økland.

According to Mr Økland, the companies have known since the 1960s that substances they sold to shipyards were very toxic and had low biodegradability. "The basis [of a suit] will be negligence liability linked to the fact that the companies have omitted to inform the recipients of the product of its PCB content and/or the possible harmful effects of this," according to Oslo law firm Advokatfirmaet Føyen & Co, which collaborated with NNV on the report.

Follow Up:
NNV , tel: +47 22 40 24 00, the report

Correction, 13/3/01
Two errors in this article have been drawn to our attention by NNV. PCBs have been found in Oslo harbour at concentrations up to 3,500 parts per billion, not 4,000 parts per million. The estimated cost of cleaning up the harbour is NKr200m (euros 24.4m), not NKr200,000. .

Please sign in to access this article. To subscribe, view our subscription options, or take out a free trial.

Please enter your details

Forgotten password?

Having trouble signing in?

Contact Customer Support at
or call 020 8267 8120

Not a subscriber?

Take a free trial now to discover the critical insights and updates our coverage offers subscribers.